Thursday, August 13, 2015

Sufficiency, Again: A Reflection for Parashat Re-eh, Friday 14 August 2015

I know that in my speaking, I tend to return to the same themes, over and over.  I imagine that when you hear me winding up to address a topic you’ve heard me address in the not-so-recent past, you cringe.  Or at least, roll your eyes!  But this is an occupational hazard.  Of my occupation, that is.  And it was anticipated.
          In my third year of rabbinical seminary, I took a year-long class in homiletics.  This is a fancy name for the art of the sermon.  The drasha, in Hebrew.  Now on the first day of our third year, we had already been giving sermons for at least a year, in conjunction with our second-year student pulpits.  The seminary faculty must have hated the people in those congregations where they sent us, to have us preach to them for a year before teaching us how to preach…
          So on the first day of that year-long class in homiletics, my teacher, Rabbi Michael Cook, told us something very jarring to our young, idealistic minds.  He told us that each one of us had One Sermon (upper case ‘S’) in us, and that we were going to struggle most of our careers until it came out the way we intended.  And then we would retire!  Along the way, we would speak on other topics, but The Sermon would always be there, trying to get out the way we wanted to say it.
          I’m not yet retired.  That should tell you that I have not yet succeeded in telling The Sermon the way it’s supposed to be told!  And since I speak over and over about one concept, you can tell that that’s the subject of The Sermon, and you can critique what I say in light of knowing its subject.
          And of course, the subject is Sufficiency.
          I told my children over and over, when they were growing up, Count your blessings!  In other words, take a good look at what you have and be thankful for it.  This, rather than ruing that, which you do not have.  Because the list of the latter will always be far longer than the list of the former.  And that holds true, no matter who you are and how much you have.
          I know of a couple who, by conventional measure, should be the happiest people I know.  They live in a palatial home.  They own both Rolls Royce and Jaguar automobiles.  They have a 107-foot superyacht, with a professional crew, at their beck and call.  They can have just about any luxury that the rest of us dream about.  But they are one of the most unhappy couples I have ever met.  And out of that unhappiness, they manipulate and exploit others to make them unhappy.  This, because they can’t allow themselves to be ‘bested’ by anybody in anything.
          Everybody knows someone like this.  Oh, the one you know might not be quite so wealthy.  Because unhappiness does not discriminate according to socioeconomic status.  But its source is usually, essentially the same.  Not counting one’s blessings.  And as a result, allowing oneself to wallow in the unhappiness that comes from not being satisfied by what one has.  From not recognising the sufficiency that one already has.
          Now, before you excoriate me for over-simplifying the sources of unhappiness.  Yes, I’m aware of the existence of mental illness.  You can’t tell someone suffering from clinical depression, or bipolar disorder, or any number of deeply debilitating disorders, to simply get over it.  I’m not here to obliterate entire disciplines of healing.  But I will say this.  Most mental disorders do not have organic causes.  A lot result from choices people make.  Drug and alcohol addictions are probably the most obvious.  Such addictions, when one develops them, must be treated as the illnesses they are.  But most times their root is that basal unhappiness that I’m talking about.  That unhappiness that comes from not finding sufficiency in what one has.  A person who is happy does not find it necessary to anesthetise his mind with recreational drugs or alcohol.  These addictions so debilitate their victims, that they lead to other disorders as one becomes less and less capable of coping.  And when one descends into the dark world of addiction and resulting mental illness, it is a difficult climb back into the light.  It takes far more than just a positive attitude.  But it is impossible without a positive attitude!  And a positive attitude from the start, an attitude of count your blessings, may have averted the abuse that lead to the descent.
          Dennis Prager wrote a book about happiness.  He called it:  Happiness is a Serious Problem.  Why is happiness, according to Prager, a problem?  \precisely because it is so elusive, for so many.  Prager makes a very provocative statement in his book.  He asserts that we are obliged to be happy.  Not that being happy is something we should afford ourselves, but he does make that point as well.  He writes that being happy is nothing short of an obligation.  And he further asserts that the obligation to be happy, comes from no less a source than the Torah.
          In this week’s portion, Re’eh, we find a glimpse into the Torah’s formula for happiness.  Moses instructs the Israelites to enjoy the bounty of the land.  To eat until satisfied.  And not just eat anything:  to eat meat in abundance, the meat of all permitted species, to enjoy an ongoing barbeque of plenty as long as they do not consume flesh with its life-blood in it.  Sorry, vegetarians!  Hashem has told us that we can eat meat:  the meat of the beasts of the field, the meat of the fowl of the air, and the meat of the fish of the sea.  Wonderful, glorious meat!  
          But then, after the instructions that might make one think that one should eat until one’s wallet is empty, we are told something else.  We must pay our tithes to sustain the worship of Hashem and the teaching of His word.  And we must take care to share what we have with the orphan, the widow, and the destitute.
          In other words, we should consume and enjoy.  But we must keep things in perspective.  Eat, drink and be merry!  But leave enough so that, if you see someone suffering, you have something left to help them.  Because that’s the key to sufficiency.  Enjoy, do not practice self-denial.  But do not consume as if there’s no tomorrow, because somewhere there is someone who needs our help.
          The couple whom I mentioned earlier is an extreme example.  Many of us think ourselves poor, or of modest means.  Since we have so little, then we’re not guilty of thinking ourselves deprived…because (of course) we are!  But each one of us enjoys blessings that we often do not see.  Yet we don’t, because our mindset is to focus on that second list, the one that’s always longer.  The list of the things we lack.  The list might include material things.  Wealth.  Good looks.  Good health.  Smarts.  Time in abundance.  If we’re honest, we know that we tend to count, and count, and count, the things that we don’t have.

          This hints at why we emphasise Shabbat so much in Jewish life.  On Shabbat, we are told to go out of our way to take delight.  And so we eat lavish meals.  And drink.  And sleep in.  And don’t run the dishwasher.  Or boot up the computer.  And find time for the things we deny ourselves the rest of the week.  I’ve just described the ideal.  If that does not sound like even a partial description of your Shabbat, then you’re denying yourself something precious.  The closer we approach that ideal, the more we achieve a feeling of well-being.  And the more we learn to reach for that well-being all week long.  Shabbat shalom. 

No comments:

Post a Comment